Live music is a visceral experience—a shared moment of connection between performers and their audience. But in a world where a concert is as much about social media posts as it is about music, the role of smartphones at gigs has sparked fierce debate. Are these devices enhancing the experience, allowing us to preserve memories and share them with the world, or are they detracting from the moment and stripping away the essence of live music?
The Case for Smartphones:
For many fans, their phone is a way to immortalise unforgettable moments. Some want to capture their favourite band on stage forever. It’s not just for them—it’s for their friends who couldn’t make it, for their future self, and for the community of fans online who share the same love.
Artists like pop star Halsey have acknowledged this desire: "Phones are part of how fans engage with music today. Seeing clips of my show shared across social media—it’s powerful. It allows the experience to extend beyond the venue."
In an era where a single video can go viral, fans also argue that phones help emerging artists gain exposure. One tweet showcasing a charismatic performance might convert casual listeners into devoted fans.
The Case Against Smartphones:
Yet, there is a growing sentiment that smartphones are diminishing the sacredness of live music. Indie rocker Laura Marling has voiced her frustration: "There’s something heartbreaking about looking out into the crowd and seeing a sea of screens instead of faces. Music is about being present, and I think phones take people out of the moment."
Concertgoers who attends gigs regularly, echo this sentiment by adding that when you're recording, you're not really there. You’re watching the performance through your screen, and you miss out on the magic happening right in front of you.
Moreover, for those who love the raw, unfiltered energy of a crowd, phones can be a physical and emotional barrier. The glare of a screen or the raised arms of someone recording can pull others out of the collective experience.
Striking the Right Balance
Some venues and artists are taking steps to reclaim the live music experience. Yondr, a company specialising in phone-free events, provides pouches for attendees to lock their devices during performances. Artists like Jack White have embraced this, stating: "I want fans to engage with the music, not their technology."
Yet, these initiatives remain divisive. While some fans appreciate the push towards mindfulness, others feel that such restrictions diminish their personal freedom.
What Do You Think?
The debate around phones at gigs is complex, touching on themes of technology, community, and artistic integrity. As gig culture continues to evolve, the question remains: Do smartphones enhance or detract from live music? Are they a tool for connection or a barrier to it?
We’d love to hear your thoughts. Do you record and share your favourite concert moments, or do you prefer to keep your phone tucked away to fully immerse yourself? Join the discussion and let us know how you feel about using mobile phones at gigs!